"The scenario is only what it is, a scenario. In reality tankers wont even be a factor because F-22s have been in Okinawa since 07. The airspace the raptors need to cover to intercept the opfor aggressors are less than 400 miles. F-22 range is 1800 miles. Keep dreaming about how Sus, Migs or Eurofighters can beat the F-22s, but it aint happening anytime soon."The range you're quoting there is actually the ferry range. That is the distance an F-22 can fly between friendly airfields. That means no weaponry + external tanks and it is a one way trip.
The combat radius is less then half that and half again typically for US aircraft if you remove the external tanks.
The F-22 has an ingeniously designed unaerodynamic shape which kinda hits the air like a hammer so it has overpowered engines to hit that air hard enough to stay in the air. The problem with that is the fuel consumption. The F-15 has a far superior range then the F-22 due to a more aerodynamic (yet not stealth) design. It is the true air superiority aircraft because it can stay in the air for some time and the Flanker series were designed to compete with that. The F-22a fits into a nice little niche left open by the last generation, where their radars and BVR and fuel capacity and agility mean little. However in order to utilise this gap you need exceptional mission planning, good intel, radar, tanking etc.
In fact you pretty much need flukish luck. You keep on saying "If you cant see them, you cant beat them." while the majority of air to air battles against equals occur either at visual range or by accidental radar contact. This is because equals deploy across the same geographic scale (in other words thinly). And in this environment the LAST thing a paranoid fighter pilot is going to do is turn his radar on and light himself up to every electronic warfare asset within 400km. So basically your F-22A's are going to rely, at best, on occasional AWACS use or maybe an intermittent 'dummy' radar surrounded by allied planes.
The problem is, all these scenarios will eventually play out, as in most battles of equals these days in the air, with pilots turning tail and running for home the moment BVR missiles get fired. Its just not practical or sensible to stick around in that kind of airspace.
So the only scenario thats going to result in a combat win, is when 2 planes, radars off, accidentally run into each other and have a knife fight. And in that scenario, fuel + engine capacity + wing area + IRST suite + WVR missiles are the only important design factors.